I have only given this 6 as a photograph, but I really really like the treatment - it makes a great picture (can you elaborate on the process?) but although I am a fan of post-processing (many on this forum are not) I'm not sure to what extent this can still be considered a photograph.... regards, Mike

Yep, some don't like it or don't see it as photography in real meaning. My answer: Many don't like Photoshop. But if a woman works on herself with lipstick etc. to make herself more beautifull, she is photoshopping, because normaly she don't look like that. If you use (old days) yellow filter, orange filter etc etc. Where are the borders of such "help'?
IMO: Creativity? Enjoy it. But also: Digital alterations should be a category aside the others.

greetz John

Yes John, this can be difficult to evaluate! You can achieve the effects by using edge-effect filters, posterisation and any number of techniques and by experimenting with these you learn how to use them.

Unfortunately one can also use "art filters" which do all the work for you but don't allow you to learn HOW they work!

To use your example of a girl putting on make-up, it is the difference between skilfully applying various cosmetic products, or simply putting on a pre-prepared mask.

regards, Mike